NYC DOB / ECB / OATH hearings · verified property resolution

4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019 — Illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy and December 2026 OATH Hearing Details

The November 10, 2026 verified-property dataset associates 1 DOB/ECB/OATH summons with 4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019 and source-listed date December 10, 2026. Recorded concerns include illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy. Below are the exact source identifiers and allegations, followed by issue-specific defense checks, correction options and evidence needed for a responsible review.

Illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy

Verified premises, hearing and enforcement snapshot

Verified premises address
4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019
Borough
Manhattan
BIN
1035074
BBL
1012730044
Source summonses
1
Hearing dates in source
December 10, 2026
Source snapshot
November 10, 2026
Address verification method
PAD exact BIN

Official PAD aliases and building ranges: 4 through 12 WEST 58 STREET

Premises precision: Official building range; low endpoint shown. A verified building-level match does not prove an exact apartment or entrance.

Source and authorship: Building Violation LLC prepared this independent property-record explanation using a November 10, 2026 DOB/OATH source extract and verified BIN/BBL property matching. The issue analysis is editorial guidance generated from source allegations and cited laws, not a new inspection or legal determination. The source sometimes abbreviates inspector text. This is not a live OATH calendar; verify dates, appearance instructions, dispositions, monetary fields and compliance directly with NYC.

What merits immediate verification: one or more Class 1 source allegations. Read the current OATH and DOB records before acting.

What is the December 2026 OATH hearing for at 4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019?

The uploaded record lists 1 summons, including 039201387H (illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy). The source-listed hearing date: December 10, 2026. These are allegations and dated extract fields; the current official notices determine the actual appearance obligation and disposition.

What should the owner or respondent do first?

Verify the status of each normalized summons with OATH, obtain the complete inspector narrative and cited order/permit records, address immediate hazards, and assemble dated evidence matched to each allegation. A Certificate of Correction or other DOB closeout may remain necessary even after an OATH hearing or payment.

December 2026 summonses and listed hearing times

Summons / lookupSource hearing date / timeSeverityRecorded subjectSource disposition
39201387H
039201387H
8:30 AM
CLASS - 1Illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancyPENDING

How this recorded summons relates at 4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019

This page documents one source-linked summons (039201387H), concerning illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy. There is no second December summons in this dataset to connect to it. Check the complete DOB property record separately for earlier or later allegations, open correction items or related agency orders.

Each violation: allegation, defense issues, correction strategy and supporting documents

Source wording is distinguished from potential actions. These are investigatory prompts, not legal advice, guaranteed defenses or promises of DOB acceptance.

Summons 1 of the source-linked property

Illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy — ECB/OATH summons 39201387H

Normalized ten-character lookup: 039201387H (infraction 107)

November 10 source-listed hearing8:30 AM

Source allegation and actual cited law

The alleged use or dwelling-unit arrangement may differ from the Certificate of Occupancy or other lawful DOB records. The exact cited location/component should be confirmed against the original inspection record.

Inspector narrative as preserved in source data

OBSERVED MOVIE THEATER (PARIS THEATER) OPERATING WITH EXPIRED TEMPARARY C OF O #122835815T010 WITH ABOUT 25 PEOPLE. EXPIRED ON 09/07/2020, OBTAIN A VALID CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY

This is the narrative supplied in the dataset; verify it against the actual signed summons and inspector attachments.

Recorded infraction numbers and cited legal provisions:
  • 107 — 28-118.2 NEW BLDG OR LOT OCCUPIED W/O A VALID C OF O
Issue date
August 21, 2026
Service date
August 21, 2026
Source severity
CLASS - 1
Source violation type
Construction
Hearing status in extract
PENDING
DOB/ECB status in extract
ACTIVE
Correction certification in extract
Not recorded
Penalty field in extract
$2,500.00
Balance field in extract
$2,500.00

Penalty and balance are fields in the supplied November 10 extract—not independently verified current fines, final adjudications or amounts presently owed.

Safety priority: Class 1 in source — treat any alleged immediately hazardous condition as urgent; verify specific DOB correction requirements.

What the alleged violation means at 4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019

Verify the legally approved building use, number of units and affected floor, then compare those records to the exact occupancy described by the inspector. Do not assume a unit is lawful or unlawful based only on a mailing address. The exact cited location/component should be confirmed against the original inspection record. Record-specific inspection detail: Inspector text begins: “OBSERVED MOVIE THEATER (PARIS THEATER) OPERATING WITH EXPIRED TEMPARARY C OF O #122835815T010 WITH ABOUT 25 PEOPLE. EXPIRED ON 09/07/2020, OBTAIN A VALID C…”

Possible defense questions and factual disputes to investigate

The following are issues to verify, not assurances that a defense applies to summons 039201387H.

  • Whether the cited space and alleged use match the actual premises and inspection period
  • Whether a valid Certificate of Occupancy, letter of no objection or approved plans authorize that use
  • Whether the described occupants, partitioning or unit configuration existed at the relevant time
  • Compare the original summons, issue/service dates and the complete inspector narrative with each document; do not assume any potential defense is established without proof.

Correction and DOB closeout strategy

  • If a hazardous or illegal occupancy exists, address safe occupancy and egress promptly.
  • Discuss restoration to approved use versus a potentially approvable legalization with a registered design professional; coordinate applications, inspections and closeout if viable.

Determine whether DOB requires a Certificate of Correction, a separate reinspection, application/permit sign-off or an order-lift. An OATH outcome, a paid fine and physical correction are separate issues.

Evidence and documents tailored to this allegation

  • current and historical Certificates of Occupancy or DOB occupancy records
  • approved floor plans, unit-count and building-use documentation
  • dated floor/interior photographs and credible usage records
  • lease or occupancy documents appropriately redacted
  • professional survey/architectural assessment and permit history

Pending in source: what to verify before acting

The November 10 extract lists the hearing as PENDING. Confirm its present scheduling, appearance method, adjournment/settlement rules and evidence deadlines directly with OATH.

Need a summons-specific action plan? For 039201387H, Building Violation LLC can scope occupancy/illegal-conversion research, hearing preparation and design-professional coordination after reviewing the actual notice and current DOB/OATH record.

Request help with illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy at 4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019
Focused NYC DOB and OATH resolution services

Resolve the actual issue at 4 West 58 Street, Manhattan, NY 10019 — not just the summons number

For this property, start with illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy. Building Violation LLC can assess an authorized paid scope for OATH hearing preparation/representation, source-record research and correction coordination appropriate to the individual allegations. A hearing defense and a DOB compliance closeout may both be necessary.

  • Illegal occupancy / certificate of occupancy (1 source summons): Occupancy/illegal-conversion research, hearing preparation and design-professional coordination.

What to send for an assessment: Bring the original summons, current OATH notices, available DOB records and photos tied to the alleged condition. The source-listed hearing date: December 10, 2026.

Services may require separate licensed-trade, architect/engineer or attorney involvement. No outcome, penalty reduction, permit or agency approval is guaranteed; professional fees and scope are confirmed before work.

Official NYC verification resources

Verify the current OATH / DOB record

This is a point-in-time source extract, not a live court calendar. Confirm the date, appearance method, hearing status, penalties and correction requirements directly with the government before taking action.