Work without a permit — ECB/OATH summons 39558516R
Normalized ten-character lookup: 039558516R (infraction 101)
Source allegation and actual cited law
DOB alleges construction, alteration, demolition or installation work without a required permit. Key locations/components named in the source: apartment or dwelling unit.
Inspector narrative as preserved in source data — potentially incomplete
AT TIME OF INSPECTION OBSERVED WORKERS IN PROGRESS OF INTERIOR PARTIAL RENOVATION OF EXISTING APARTMENT R2 ON SECOND FLOOR. UPON REVIEWING DOB NOW AND BIS SYSTEM REVEAL NO PERMIT FOUND/OBTAIN IN ADDITION UPON R
The supplied record stops at its extract limit and may omit the rest of the inspector narrative. Obtain the complete original summons before making a factual or legal decision.
- 101 — 28-105.1 WORK WITHOUT A PERMIT
- Issue date
- August 28, 2026
- Service date
- August 28, 2026
- Source severity
- CLASS - 1
- Source violation type
- Construction
- Hearing status in extract
- PENDING
- DOB/ECB status in extract
- ACTIVE
- Correction certification in extract
- Not recorded
- Penalty field in extract
- $2,500.00
- Balance field in extract
- $2,500.00
Penalty and balance are fields in the supplied November 10 extract—not independently verified current fines, final adjudications or amounts presently owed.
Safety priority: Class 1 in source — treat any alleged immediately hazardous condition as urgent; verify specific DOB correction requirements.
What the alleged violation means at 58-84 Winthrop Street, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Determine which physical work is alleged, when it was performed and whether an approved filing/permit covered that scope at inspection. A permit issued after the inspection does not by itself establish that the charge was invalid when issued. Key locations/components named in the source: apartment or dwelling unit. Record-specific inspection detail: Inspector text begins: “AT TIME OF INSPECTION OBSERVED WORKERS IN PROGRESS OF INTERIOR PARTIAL RENOVATION OF EXISTING APARTMENT R2 ON SECOND FLOOR. UPON REVIEWING DOB NOW AND BIS…”
Possible defense questions and factual disputes to investigate
The following are issues to verify, not assurances that a defense applies to summons 039558516R.
- Whether the work identified in the summons actually took place at the cited premises
- Whether the work was exempt, previously permitted, or covered by approved plans at the relevant time
- Whether the named respondent or owner had the responsibility alleged under the cited provision
- Compare the original summons, issue/service dates and the complete inspector narrative with each document; do not assume any potential defense is established without proof.
Correction and DOB closeout strategy
- Confirm which work can lawfully remain and whether legalization, permits or removal/restoration is necessary.
- Have a registered architect, engineer or licensed trade assess design, safety, permitting and inspection requirements as appropriate.
Determine whether DOB requires a Certificate of Correction, a separate reinspection, application/permit sign-off or an order-lift. An OATH outcome, a paid fine and physical correction are separate issues.
Evidence and documents tailored to this allegation
- approved unit layout and relevant lawful occupancy records
- historical DOB NOW/BIS permits, applications, approvals and sign-offs
- approved architectural or engineering plans and amendments
- dated photographs of the exact cited work or area
- contracts, invoices and contractor or tenant work records
- permit or restoration evidence and final inspections
Pending in source: what to verify before acting
The November 10 extract lists the hearing as PENDING. Confirm its present scheduling, appearance method, adjournment/settlement rules and evidence deadlines directly with OATH.
Need a summons-specific action plan? For 039558516R, Building Violation LLC can scope work-without-permit hearing review and legalization/removal scope after reviewing the actual notice and current DOB/OATH record.
Request help with work without a permit at 58-84 Winthrop Street, Brooklyn, NY 11225